Pardon my absence, I’ve been distracted by the current round of idiocy flaring up at my children’s elementary school.
The principal has decided that our young children need to be quiet during lunch. To achieve this bizarre goal she is using the cafeteria sound system, deplorable music and three workers to impose silence on our little guys. The children all hate it and I’ve already been in contact with the bureaucrat responsible for this flakey policy.
Since she remained adamantly unconvinced of my contrary arguments to her visionary idea of a Carthusian lunch room, I spent an hour dining with my children today to get the true flavor of her latest experiment in modern educational child management techniques. I have not spent a more surreal hour since I dropped acid in a rain soaked pine forest back around 1978.
Children would be happily chattering away at normal levels, then new age, Enya lite music emanating from the stage speakers would assault the senses. The lunch workers would hold their arms overhead, fingers shaped in a V of peace, followed by a loud round of sibilant shushing. As the children ceased speaking, the ladies would stalk the aisles, telling the few brave whispering souls to be quiet and these women weren’t being polite about the demand. Two of the harridans looked unkept and hungover, their faces etched in perpetual scowls as they fussed our small children into unnatural silence. One woman had the unmitigated gall to physically move the boy seated next to my son further down the bench. He had been cozied up to my Tom, enjoying a whispered conversation with us, she didn’t have the balls to shush me, but you should have seen the humiliation on his sweet face. The bitch ruined his day.
I had one laugh out loud moment when the second round of music ended and the entire lunchroom erupted in cheers! Of course they were immediately told cheering wouldn’t be tolerated and if they did it again the music would be played for longer periods. Killjoys.
I stayed for lunch with my older son, it was rather disturbing that the music played almost the whole of his thirty minute break – we didn’t get a real chance to visit. Perhaps the principal doesn’t want parents sharing the occasional school lunch with their children anymore, because I found it damn near impossible to have a normal conversation under her cone of silence.
It was weird watching these nice, sheltered kids keep a caged eye out for the monitors. Thirty minutes of lunch had turned into a subversive act, pitting the normalcy of seven year olds against an unnatural rule. I saw dozens of small, open faces take on the slyness of craft or morph into blandness as the keepers made their rounds. That’s not right, what in the hell are they teaching in this environment, the art of deception?
I found it telling that the principal was informed of my presence and came scurrying down the aisle to make nice shortly after I arrived. I have a small reputation of issuing disagreeable opinions weighing contrary to prevailing administrative thought. It’s not a pleasant role, I’d rather not give the head office another thought, but with this sort of blinding insanity regularly rearing it’s demented head, I feel compelled to weigh in with a bit of ornery sensibility.
Our cafeteria holds two hundred kids at a time, seven hundred of them file through this two-story, cinder block room five days a week. The vast majority are well mannered and respectful, these aren’t rowdy, misbehaved children. No doubt that it can be loud in the lunch room, sounds echo, but the administration needs to either accept that normal children need to be allowed to act normal during one of their brief breaks in a seven hour instructional day or they should spend some of the substantial PTA funds they raise every year on sound deadening insulation to alleviate the staff’s complaints.
School isn’t about creating an atmosphere conducive to the administration, teachers or lunchroom monitor’s comfort. It is about educating our children and trusting that those in charge appreciate the solid fact that these short people we entrust to their care nine months out of the year aren’t actually smaller versions of themselves. I find it beyond irritating that these folks seem to forget that they work for me. These educators are my employees and I have never taken kindly to any of my expensive nine to fivers treating the customers badly. My children are the customers this time around and that is the last place you want test my gracious patience.

I have a small reputation of issuing disagreeable opinions weighing contrary to prevailing administrative thought. It’s not a pleasant role, I’d rather not give the head office another thought, but with this sort of blinding insanity regularly rearing it’s demented head, I feel compelled to weigh in with a bit of ornery sensibility.
Wow, can I ever relate to this.
Unfortunately, the school admins with whom I have my real beef have been out of the picture for a couple of years now. We’re still finding residual effects of the damage they caused, with a mindset very similar to the one you’re describing here.
School isn’t about creating an atmosphere conducive to the administration, teachers or lunchroom monitor’s comfort. It is about educating our children and trusting that those in charge appreciate the solid fact that these short people we entrust to their care nine months out of the year aren’t actually smaller versions of themselves.
Bingo. A rather timeless parents’ complaint, I believe.
It’s not pleasant bucking the system, Morgan, they get all affronted and distressed when you call them on their bullshit.
Children are so easy, these professionals make it unnaturally difficult.
That sounds fucking Dickensian. I had visions of Oliver Twist and the workhouse in a bizarre new age setting reading that.
Teachers generally exist to crush the confidence out of the kids over whom they have any charge. The ones I remember with fondness from a young age are the ones who bucked that trend and so made an impact in my life. They also commanded my respect and obedience as a result.
I like to say that nothing surprises me anymore. I stand corrected.
That sounds appalling. You are quite correct – that won’t teach them to be quiet. All it will do is teach them to lie and hide and dissemble. What a load. Good on you for being a thorn in their sides.
Hey, Andy! I’ve missed you.
Alison, I’m in an excellent school district and a quality school, grappling with the fucked up mind set of these people is infuriating.
A hundred years ago — well, maybe closer to 15 or 20 — the powers that be tried the same sort of BS at my girls’ elementary school. Fortunately, at that time, there was no Enya (Egad!), so there was no “soothing” music, just lots of finger-pointing, snapping of fingers, and shushing. After a group of us rowdy parent-folk started joining our children for lunch and carrying on conversations with them in normal, albeit mildly toned-down, decibel levels on a regular basis (they wouldn’t waggle a finger at us), the “experiment” was modified — they installed a stoplight in the cafeteria. When the noise level started going up, the light went to yellow; when it got “unacceptable,” the light changed to red and a siren went off! The kids hated that siren — it was RELLY annoying! (It had to be worse for the rest of the school than noisy children relishing their freedom from the classroom!) I had forgotten about that stoplight until just now. Thanks for another memory!
Kids don’t get to be kids anymore! Not enough time to run around outdoors to burn off excess energy; not enough time to goof off inside their own imaginations at home without having to participate in some “structured activity.” Hell, they can’t even ride their bikes in the front yard for fear that some pervert will snatch them and keep them locked up somewhere in a faux backyard for 18 years.
I predict that your kids’ school’s grand experiment could have dire consequences — 20 years from now, I envision that one of their classmates will climb a tower at some university with gigantic speakers in tow, hell-bent on punishing and torturing the innocent malcontents in his vicinity with Enya playing on an endless do-loop. Extra helpings of the “soothing music” were presented as a punishment at his elementary school, after all. Ah — such a preventable tragedy!
I’d like to think you didn’t have to knock their heads together all on your own but I’m betting the other parents are disinterested? If not I hope you can get it sorted and shove Enya up their collective tight arses.
Alison, I have been working the parent network like mad, we’ll see if they get righteously tiffed too.
If not, I may be looking at moving my kids to another school. This is flat out unacceptable. I wish you could have been there with me, it was the weirdest thing I’ve ever experienced. Our principal is a complete fruitcake if she believes this acceptable.
Moogie,
I don’t think these people can see past their noses.
The disconnect between discerning normative behavior hedged against unnatural social dictates and the potential long term consequences of sociative educational programing is quite disturbing.
I have less respect for the teaching profession as the years pass.
That’s just @#$%ing madness!
Glad my kids are not at that school, or the police would be dragging me away from the serious beating I’d be trying to deliver to those idiots. (of course, I wouldn’t do that, but I sure as heck can think it)
If that isn’t a reason to homeschool, nothing is.
Probably the best that can be done is to get as many parents as possible to complain about it to try to get it changed.
As for the delicate ears, issue them bloody earplugs
I have not spent a more surreal hour …
Surreal is the perfect word. Damn, but I’m glad I’m not involved with the public school system these days. Throw in the Obamination indoctrination exercise… and just: Damn.
Full disclosure: My 12 year old is being home-schooled.
Tocqueville described visiting a work prison in New York State, where the prisoners were what we would call today career criminals. Absolute silence was employed as their primary method of control, and it was vigorously and sucessfully enforced.
There is no decent reason for government schools to exist any longer. In 100 years we have gone from teaching Latin and Greek in high schools, to teaching remedial English in college, and silence at lunch. Worse, we pay for the indocrination of our children and suffer paying for the indignity. Like government, when we think we will reform it, it ends by reforming us.
Carthusian lunch room.
I almost just peed myself I was laughing so hard.
Somewhere, Mencken is smiling.
It is written that those who cannot hack it in the real areas of engineering school gravitate to the school of Industrial Management, and those who cannot hack it at University gravitate to the Schools of Education and Journalism.
Methinks this supposition is validated by Real Life.
Pediatric Principal Proves Peter Principle Pertinent!
I taught for 15 years (8-10 yr olds). There’s a mindset in the teachers I worked with that values the ability to “control” their classrooms. Control children, really.
Over time I came to the conclusion that whatever control we had was granted, freely or grudgingly, by the children. If you had their respect, you had their cooperation. “Control” wasn’t necessary.
By the time I left the teaching world, I had very few rules to enforce. Being quiet for quiet’s sake was not one of them. Nor was walking in straight lines.
Pity help the child with ADHD and/or sensory sensitivity.
I can see the benifits of having a place where kids can be quiet and have relaxing sounds played to them. Making it compulsory and at the time they are eating is madness.
I also wonder what this could do to anyoen with the potential to have an eating disorder or any unhealthy association with food.
I hope you and kid well being wins this!
For many years I was the prickle under the saddle for the urban cowboys trying to break the spirits of my children.
I am pleased to report that, while they may have succeeded with other families, they had no such luck with us. My eldest son demanded and got the right to be called by just his first name at the graduation ceremony; there are a thousand other examples of his and his siblings’ distaste for having their souls and constitutional freedoms squashed.
What a sad commentary on modern life, that we must joust with our local fellow citizens for the rights and dignity of our children.
Once again, you have done the right and good and admirable thing, Daphne. Five stars for the hour in the lunchroom and the harassment of the educational gestapo.
Reading this brought up a memory from over 50 years ago. It was 1956-57 at an elementary school in rural California. This was a facility with 6 classrooms (one for each grade – there was no K) and an office for the principal and his secretary. There was a blacktop with a couple of basketball backboards, two or three tether ball stands and lines painted for hopscotch, four square and dodgeball. There was also a large open field where we could go play kickball or softball or just run around.
One of our activities at lunch was to play “war”. One side was the Americans and the other side was the Japs or Germans. There was almost always a battle of some kind being waged on that field during the lunch hour. The day I remember was unusual though because on that day every kid in the school played “war”. Boys and girls, first graders and 6th graders, all joined one side or the other and refought WWII. “POWS” and “BANGS” and “RATA-TAT-TATS” were shouted. There were trees out there and dead branches on the ground and these quickly became machine guns and rifles. Kids were dropping like flies with yells and groans as they were shot down (to be quickly resurrected to rejoin the battle – sometimes on the side that just “killed” them). This went on for over half-an-hour with charges and counter charges and kids getting good and sweaty and dirty and having a great time. The Americans won in the end – they always did.
The entire teaching staff including the office lady and the principle witnessed this. It was an unusal day because never before (or after) did all of us go to “war” at lunch. So when over 100 kids started charging back and forth across that field it drew an audience of adults. Who never said a word to any of us. But they did laugh and point at some of the better “deaths” being performed (especially by the little kids).
It was a good day for us. The little kids rarely played with the big kids. You all know how that works – little kids get in the way and big kids are too impatient and rough so the two just don’t mix well. But on that day everybody got involved and everybody had fun. I have never forgotten it and every time I read something like this essay I am instantly reminded of that day.
Two words.
Home. Schooling.
At *our* lunchroom today was a spirited discussion about if the catapult the boys just built in the backyard would hurl the Triple H action figure farther than the little blue teddy bear. After the battle lines were drawn (the 12 year old and the 7 year old voted bear, the 10 and 9 year old the plastic wrestler). Dessert was delayed for empirical testing and, after I plucked the bear from the tree, we returned to discuss the mathematics of trajectories with the help of the ‘Guns! Guns! Guns! 3rd edition’ roleplaying game supplement over fruit cocktail.
I still had leaves on my back when I read about this travesty of an ‘education setting’.
Holy CRAP.
And to think I blithely sent my son off to public Kindergarten for the first time yesterday. I had no idea.
I wonder if they impose silence in the faculty lounge.
There is no reason to impose a silence (or Enya) on children during their lunch break and any teacher with any sense would know that the release of the lunch break and recess is necessary.
Has it ever occurred to these nematodes that lunch is also a time for the kids to socialize with each other?
Don’t teach . . . err . . . “educators” go on “retreats” these days on the taxpayers’ dime? How about a retreat that consists of total sensory deprivation, for, like, a week. No lights, no sound, hoods.
“It was weird watching these nice, sheltered kids keep a caged eye out for the monitors. Thirty minutes of lunch had turned into a subversive act, pitting the normalcy of seven year olds against an unnatural rule. I saw dozens of small, open faces take on the slyness of craft or morph into blandness as the keepers made their rounds. That’s not right, what in the hell are they teaching in this environment, the art of deception?”
I’m not sure whether to laugh or cry after reading this statement.
On one hand, this vicious act of forcing young spirits into a one-size-fits-all mold will begin a spirit of rebellion against ruthless conformity.
On the other hand, that spirit of rebellion against authority can easily become twisted and perverted to turn into criminal behavior and ultimately into the root of rejection against the authority of God.
Really, public education is mostly founded on principles of behavior modification and controlling the restless natives. Loads of high-minded, lofty sentiments from the do-gooders, but in the end, it is a form of social control. Read Dewey, if you don’t believe me. Then read John Taylor Gatto.
Like Allison I had a vison in my head reading this, but my cafeteria monitors were in mid calf gray dresses, hair in a bun, and nazi armbands. I’m also not shocked you are considered a thorn in the admins side. I’m sure we havent heard the last of this, can’t wait to hear how it plays out.
I have to say that I’m speechless and that doesn’t often happen .When it does it’s usually the result of bureaucratic stupidity like this.
I spent my early educational years in Catholic schools, not the concentration camps some people would have you believe, but not slackerly dens of leniency either. I don’t believe it would ever have occurred to the priests and nuns to expect total silence from us during lunch.
@scory – Today you’d all be given counselling if you weren’t expelled outright for your overtly “violent” behaviour.
I occasionally come to your blog and I enjoy reading your writing.
I am the father of 4 children. I understand your frustration and the frustration of all the commentators.
Buttt…. I do have to say this… what are you guys???? Men or pussies??? Grow some balls and stand up to these people for crying out loud.
You all are acting like you have no power. Take your kids out of school dammit. Quit letting bureaucrats raise your children.
When she physically moved the boy talking to your Tom you said she didnt have the balls to shush you….
I see it differently… YOU didnt have the balls to confront her.
Bill Henry
Bill Henry, causing a scene that would further humiliate this boy and upset the other children would have been irresponsible.
I chose to call his mother, visit our principal, and notify the superintendent and school board members.
I think you have a misguided of idea balls, Bill. They need to be used properly to be effective. Hollering at the ceiling doesn’t mean you’ve gotten the job done.
Touche.
His mother? Did the child have a father?? and No , trust me I know what balls look like.
The little boy needed to see an adult come to his defense. You would not have caused him humiliation, but you would have given him encouragement by showing him what adults do when children are abused.
He needed to know someone was in his corner.
You are still making excuses.
Hollering at the ceiling?? I dont understand, I didnt say anytthing about hollering, but defense is not pretty.
Confrontation is not simple and pretty.
Confrontation is messy and scarey. That is my whole point, people are to afraid to raise a stink, so they quietly try to change things.
One of the biggest problems with public schools is the overt feminization of them.
The public school system is broken. Complaining about it and what we should do to fix it is like talking about putting brakes on a bus that is falling over a cliff.
I only correct and criticize because from what I have read and seen on your blog you have a passion for justice and doing the right thing.
The right thing is to stop abusive behavior towards children in its tracks. When it happens. Not later by “calling” someone else about it.
And… touche??? give me a break…
Bill Henry
I see both sides of this little dust-up. Bill Henry does have a point, a lot of these awful things are happening because they aren’t being well-thought-out, and a lot of these things aren’t being well-thought-out because there isn’t any reason to think them out — they aren’t being challenged.
But Bill, that doesn’t mean Daphne behaved inappropriately. You say you read this blog. If you don’t know Daphne has balls, bigger & brassier than most men, I have to wonder how much reading you’ve been doing.
Anyone who has any experience with this all-worshipped culture of “confronting” whatsoever, knows that when a confrontation takes place it is necessary for the confronting party to define the goal of the confrontation. This breaks down into two major categories of purpose: Is a new alliance being forged, or is an old one being fractured? As is always the case with all other human affairs, those who seek to destroy carry a relatively insignificant burden, having been liberated from the obligation of caution. Once you’re about to send someone packing with the print of your boot on the seat of his pants, you don’t give a rat’s ass what his values are and you have no reason to care. So confront away.
But if you’re trying to fix something, it becomes necessary to pick your battles. This does not manifest the absence of balls, but rather the presence of a brain. Teachers who do not want to be given messages, especially obviously-true ones, are skilled and practiced in the art of deception. Especially when they practice it upon themselves, consciously seeking to become distracted. Really. Take it from a fellow parent.
In fact, if this is news to you, I must congratulate you on the breakneck speed with which you must have yanked your gang-of-four out of there; because it really doesn’t take that many meetings with teachers for the perceptive parent to see this for himself.
My “touche” to Daphne was for her gently schooling you on the difference between male and female “balls”.
I myself would not have been as polite.
The “V” of Peace?
It doesn’t sound Dickensonian. It sounds Orwellian.
My wife retires in 5 years. Wonder how she would feel about homeschooling our grandson.
Sail Away! Sail Away! Sail Away!
Soothing music… The V of peace…
Sounds like that Dead Keneddys song, remember?
“The happiness you demanded is now MANDATORY!”
“California Uber Alles”
I am Governor Jerry Brown
My aura smiles
And never frowns
Soon I will be president…
Carter Power will soon go away
I will be Fuhrer one day
I will command all of you
Your kids will meditate in school
Your kids will meditate in school!
[Chorus:]
California Uber Alles
California Uber Alles
Uber Alles California
Uber Alles California
Zen fascists will control you
100% natural
You will jog for the master race
And always wear the happy face
Close your eyes, can’t happen here
Big Bro’ on white horse is near
The hippies won’t come back you say
Mellow out or you will pay
Mellow out or you will pay!
[Chorus]
Now it is 1984
Knock-knock at your front door
It’s the suede/denim secret police
They have come for your uncool niece
Come quietly to the camp
You’d look nice as a drawstring lamp
Don’t you worry, it’s only a shower
For your clothes here’s a pretty flower.
DIE on organic poison gas
Serpent’s egg’s already hatched
You will croak, you little clown
When you mess with President Brown
When you mess with President Brown